|
WHAT WOULD AN ELDER DO? LESSONS
FROM THE LOSS OF A PARENT Reverend Caryl Hurtig Casbon May 25, 2003 Good morning.
It is wonderful to be back with you, this Memorial Weekend, after what has been a very long winter for me. I looked back on
my notes from the last time I spoke and remembered how I talked about suffering, and making a guest house for our difficult
times in life. Well, I certainly have had a great opportunity to practice what I preach, so to speak. I am going to try to
share my experience with you, even as I am still living into it, in hopes that there will be some benefit to you or some connection
to your life.
Something I have known for a long time is how important
it is that we share our stories with one another. There is great healing in telling our stories, and the potential for true
connection and learning in the telling. It is one very important ways we make sense of our lives, and live with complexity.
Frederic Beuchner, a German theologian, has this to say about stories:
On Telling Our Stories…
“My story is important not because it is mine…but
because if I tell it anything like right, the chances are you will recognize that in many ways it is yours. Maybe nothing
is more important than that we keep track…of these stories of who we are and where we have come from and the people
we have met along the way because it is precisely through these stories in all their particularity that God makes himself
(herself) known to each of us most powerfully and personally…to lose track of our stories is to be profoundly impoverished
not only humanly but spiritually. I not only have my secrets, I am my secrets. And you are yours. Our secrets are human secrets,
and our trusting each other enough to share them with each other has much to do with the secret of what it means to be human.”
So bear with me as I share with you a story from my recent
life: the story of the loss of my mother. All my life I have felt that I wasn’t sure I could stand to lose my mother,
and I have been very blessed with having both of my parents live into their 80’s, to get a chance to know them over
many years and through the lens of my own maturing eyes.
Right after the Christmas holidays, my mother starting
experiencing severe pain in her back, and after several weeks ended up in the hospital with emergency surgery on her lower
back. At that time we all believed her difficulty was a little fall she had taken, and the surgery was to correct the damage
from that. I flew down to care for her when she got out of the hospital, only to watch her further suffer as she lost the
use of her legs, and continued to experience tremendous pain. As time went on she was put into a rehabilitation hospital to
try to help her adjust to her paralysis, and to our horror, she just kept getting worse. After more trips to California, spinal
taps, MRI’s and more pain for Mom, they finally decided that she had a rare disease where her immune system attacked
her spine. They did some intensive drug therapy to try to arrest the paralysis, and she came out of that even weaker, and
finally died on April 8th when her heart gave out. It was like watching someone fall off a cliff in slow motion, helpless
to stop the fall, but noting the progress in all its stages, never really being able to comprehend that she would actually
hit the bottom. All the safety nets full of holes, my own denial and hope insulating me from believing what was really going
on.
As I look back on this stage of losing Mom, I am struck
by how we grasped to hang on to how we had always had Mom, healthy, mentally alert and in charge, how we resisted knowing
the truth of what was unfolding in front of our eyes: she was dying. I am reminded now of Buddhist teachings around impermanence,
and how much I fight that awareness when it is so vividly in my face. Pema Chodrin, in her book, The Places That Scare You,
states it so well:
“That nothing is static or fixed, that all is fleeting
and impermanent, is the first mark of existence. It is the ordinary state of affairs. Everything is in process. Everything---every
tree, every blade of grass, all the animals, insects, human beings, buildings, the animate and inanimate---is always changing,
moment to moment. We don’t have to be mystics or physicists to know this. Yet at the level of personal experience, we
resist this basic fact. It means that life isn’t always going to go our way. It means there’s loss as well as
gain. And we don’t like that….Because we take what is always changing to be permanent, we suffer.”
Jay came home last night and noted how much change is going
on at his new college. We dedicated the new building this fall, with a plack honoring the people that were instrumental in
building it, and now, all but one person on the plack has moved on, and he is retiring! So change is rapid and all about us.
My family’s way of resisting the fact of my mother’s
decline, was to continue to hope that medical interventions would help her, could fix it, could save her. I don’t think
this was wrong, but perhaps by focusing so much on this, we may have missed other ways of being with her as she went through
this long passage into death. As much experience I have in this area, it was really hard for me to have much perspective in
my own situation.
I did have enough warning that she was not doing well that
there was time for visits with Mom, and time to realize that we may be losing her, or even if she did live, it would be in
extremely compromised conditions. My family was changed forever. Everyone kept asking me if I was preparing, and I found it
hard to know what it means to prepare for a death. I didn’t feel any great ‘unfinished business’ or any
huge issue looming between us. I felt helpless to protect her from what was occurring and very concerned about my Dad. I was
facilitating a retreat the weekend before her death, and someone there mentioned that he wished that he had apologized to
his mother for some of his behavior, but couldn’t because of her death. I decided to do some journaling that weekend
around that question, since there was a period during and after college when I was quite a self-righteous jerk about politics
and lifestyle issues, a period of rebellion….but as I wrote, I realized that what I really wanted to say to Mom was
“thank you.” Thank for you all of the millions of times she really listened to me, thank you for all of the times
she didn’t give me advise when I was making really bad decisions, thank you for getting me into Camp Fire Girls and
putting up with all of those endless tacky craft projects, sending me to camp, and welcoming my friends and family over the
years.
But when I got back to Bend after the retreat, she was
feeling worse. We talked about her nausea and lack of appetite, and how irritated she was with the physical therapy. She couldn’t
understand why they didn’t know how rotten she felt, and why they wouldn’t leave her alone. My mother was a nutritionist
and the last thing she said to me the day she died was that all they do is feed old people sweet things in these places, a
certain sacrilege for someone who put Tabasco sauce on oatmeal! This was not a deeply spiritual conversation, as you can tell.
A few hours later she passed over, leaving her tired body behind. By this point, I had been praying for her to have an easy
transition to the other side, and that she be released from this body that was torturing her and diminishing any quality of
life she had left. She was not a person who would want to live like this. My sister called that afternoon to warn me that
they were taking her to the hospital and were going to perform life-saving procedures on her. My first reaction was to say,
“Oh, Sue, don’t’ let them do that. We have to let her go.” Later we found out that she probably died
on the way to the hospital.
I wasn’t there, but I knew that it was important
that someone sit with her in the hospital as she was making this transition out of her body, so I asked Sue, my sister, to
do this, even though she had little experience with this sort of thing. In many cultures, people sit vigil with a body and
pray for the person for many days and even weeks. Mom had her cell phone clutched in her hand on the way to the hospital,
and when I called Sue back on her cell phone as she sat vigil with Mom, she asked me if I wanted to talk to Mom. The absurdity
and rightness of this struck me and I sobbed my blessings and assurances to my mom on the cell phone, about how she was safe
to move on, that she was in the loving protection of the Divine, that we were ok, and we knew she would be free of her tortured
body. I think of this now as a little example of how we all pulled together in this time and operated out of the box as the
situation demanded. Truly in death, there are no boundaries to expressing our love and connection.
As my mother’s health declined, my parents were still
living in the home they built fifty three years ago, and it was clear that they would need to move to accommodate mom’s
worsening condition and nursing needs, so we sold the house and arranged to have them move to a facility where both of them
could live while mom was in nursing care. When she died, the house had been sold, but Dad was still living in it. So, we were
faced with not only handling the funeral and a huge party afterwards, but then closing out our family home, and the intense
emotional attachment to that place that held us together for so long, packing things up, figuring out where Dad would want
to live now that Mom was gone, and his intense grief after 62 years of marriage…this was so much change at once. My
sister and I basically spent 3 weeks working with all of these endings. I conducted the memorial service where over 100 old
friends going back to their college years were able to attend, and where Dad and my family could say goodbye to the community
where we grew up and left for our adult lives. In the memorial, I was able to say thank you to my mother as well. My grief
was put on hold as my father’s needs took front row. I found myself packing boxes for him, comforting him in the moments
I watched him stand before my mother’s portrait, kiss it, and cry. I talked with him about his fears of living alone
in this new community of people he didn’t know, after depending so fiercely on my mother’s strength and leadership
during their years together. It began to feel like this tremendous role reversal, and I was sending him off to college. Or
graduate school. In many ways, it was a tender time, and I am grateful we could cushion his transition into widowhood.
While there is nothing especially unique in my story, for
we all, if we live long enough, face losing our parents. A friend of mine said to me in the midst of this that losing her
mother was a very precious and deep time for her. I have been trying to hold that intention and learn from this season of
loss as I pass through it. I would like to focus this morning on some of the lessons I am learning about grief, and change
and life, and also invite you to share some of your thoughts at the end of the service. It only makes sense to offer these
reflections to one another in a spiritual community. I once heard someone say that if our faith community can’t help
us with death, what can? That’s a worthy question.
Now that we have Dad moved in to where he is going to live,
now that the house is gone and lifetime of belongings have been divided up and shared in the family, now that I am back in
the comfort and solitude of my own home in Bend, I find myself on a journey of grief. It feels like an initiation of sorts.
Mircea Eliade, in his book, Rites and Symbols of Initiation,
describes the basic pattern of initiations in different cultures:
First the torture at the hands of spirits; second, the
ritual death; third the resurrection to a new mode of being. Through initiation we die to what we are; we do not emerge from
these ordeals as the same person.
In “A Gathering of Men,” Robert Bly describes
a ritual still practiced today in New Guinea, where the boy who is considered ready for initiation into manhood undergoes
a ritual enactment of separation. Armed with spears, he and his mother walk onto a bridge. They are met by a group of men,
also armed, who threaten to take the boy. The boy clings to his mother, looking to her to protect him as she always has. But
this time is different. The time for separation has come, and after a long mock battle the boy is led by the men away from
his mother. They take him to an island where he is isolated from the rest of the community. After weeks or months he emerges
as a man with a new name and place in the community. He has died as a boy and been reborn as a man.
In telling this story in Alexandra Kennedy’s book,
Losing a Parent, she notes how this initiation ritual serves as a metaphor for what we pass through when a parent dies. The
death of a parent, in true initiatory fashion, shakes up the very foundation of our lives, and does away a sense of protection
our parent has always provided.
What was apparent almost immediately, was, much like the
adolescent boy in the initiation, how stripped down I felt, and how exaggerated everything seemed. I felt like I was in shock.
My parent’s relationship was laid bare, exposed to the Truth as all of their patterns were amplified at the end. Next
to a deep commitment of 62 years, there were many tensions and patterns that were not especially healthy for either of them,
and my sister and I found ourselves listening to my mother’s intense frustration with this primary relationship in her
life as she lay helpless in the hospital. She had real regrets. My father had developed a great dependency on her, and even
as she was getting worse, much of our energy went into helping him learn some basic life skills so he could become more self-sufficient
to begin living on his own…how to use the washing machine, how to make coffee, pick up his clothes, and so on. I learned
how very important our partners are in our lives, how much this primary relationship shapes so much of our life experience,
and to tend carefully to how this relationship unfolds. Our relationships to others have a real presence at our deaths, and
the question of ‘right relation’ arises.
During mom’s illness I saw how the world was turned
upside down, where, even when sick and elderly, life demands so much of us. My Mother, who was always in control and so active,
faced a total loss of control and paralysis. My father, who had leaned into my mother’s strength and became almost helpless
in that leaning, was faced with coming to terms with becoming independent, standing on his own two feet, at age 88. I had
to wonder what big issue would be in my face at this stage of my life.
I realized that there is unfinished business at the end
of one’s life, and to accept that. One’s life is never easily wrapped up, even at the end, and this is probably
normal. I can’t think of many times so far where all has felt wrapped up. A life is not a Hollywood movie. I saw their
generations’ contracts between husband and wife, and asked my self how my generation is doing. What a gift to be living
these questions.
I also found myself asking, as I prepared the memorial
service, “What was the meaning of my mother’s life?” I think this is one of the big questions a death confronts
us with, and one of the great values for me in writing the memorial service was to explore this question in depth. I found
myself struck by how another person’s life, even one’s mother’s, is, on some level, a mystery. As I discussed
this with Jay, he made the comment that he thought that all of us were entitled to our mysteries, and I think that there is
truth and wisdom in this perspective.
I was asking hard questions: What was unlived in her life?
Why did so many people gravitate to her? What was the source of her strength? Who was she really? What did she take on incarnation
for in order to learn? and so on. Of course, once I started asking these questions in any sort of focused way about my mother,
I also started asking these questions about my own life.
In grief, the inwardness and withdrawal from life that
goes on is demanding in its call for a reflection of how I am living, and what I am living for. The boy in the initiation
is sent off to an island, and part of me thinks that the grieving person should do the same. The boy is at first surrounded
by the armed men, and at first, I was cushioned by the love of my family, all of the business of taking care of everything,
and the disarming compassion from friends and my husband, Jay. I was so touched by the love and support that poured out, and
felt renewed in our human capacity to love one another through these times…the great human capacity for compassion and
love.
But at a point, it was time for seclusion, to face the
loss before me alone. I find myself, not exactly depressed, but extremely tired much of the time, and vulnerable to more self-criticism,
with less energy for regular life. A loss like this puts one in shock, and I am coming to realized that the way back to more
‘normal life’ is to take a little piece of the experience each day, and work with small insights, memories, or
dreams, and gradually digest it. As I do this, I find myself gradually coming back to life as well. I think there is just
so much one can digest at one time, and this quiet process is very healing.
I find myself revisiting my questions of faith, especially in what is unseen, and in what I
believe happens when we die. I find myself listening for and feeling my mother’s presence, listening to my dreams, and
tuning in to more subtle spiritual messages. I sense this is a fragile and time-limited yet timeless state.
Alexandra Kennedy highly recommends what she calls a sanctuary time when in grief. For a certain
part of the day, to set aside some time for meditation, journaling, and solitude, and to let the grief work for you. If you
honor grief, it has much to reveal.
Stephanie Erickson states, “Grief is a sacred time when we rearrange our fragments into a
new definition of wholeness.”
There is an opening in our lives, and our family structures at the time of loss; it is a great
opportunity, but our culture doesn’t help us much take advantage of it. Life marches on for all around you. I truly
believe that it is a sacred passage from which we can return to life in a manner where we know ourselves as different, where
we open our hearts to the loss and therefore to others’ pain, and where, through our spiritual practices, find a new
relationship with our parent by learning to communicate in new ways. Grief is nothing to be feared, but to honor and respect
for what it holds for us. It is something to make a guesthouse for.
In many cultures, the village recognizes this loss in some outward ways as well. The person grieving
may cut their hair off, or give away all of their possessions, and at the end of a formal grieving period, hold a party and
mark the ending of this initial stage of living without their loved one. At the last retreat I was facilitating, just before
my Mom died, one of the participants asked me to perform a ceremony where I was to cut her hair off to mark the end of her
season of darkness after the death of her only son 3 years ago. She wrote an incredible story about how she stopped caring
about her appearance after her son died, and had just let her hair grow. Recently her friends started mentioning that, “Gee,
maybe you would look better if you had your hair styled.” She is in her 60’s, and stringy, long hair was not flattering.
She realized this spring that the shadow of her grief for her son was finally lifting, and she was ready to be back in the
world in a new way, after a long season of grief. She could start caring again about her appearance, and cutting her hair
was a symbol of that inward spring she was feeling. You could literally see a difference in her face, and witnessing the cutting
of her hair in community was a powerful and intimate moment of celebration. She showed up with lots of new clothes, a refreshed
spirit, and a readiness to go forward with life. What a joy.
I am not there yet….I am not through my season of grief, and I sense that my mother’s
death also is an initiation for me, not an initiation into adolescence, but into my own elder hood. On some deep level I realize
that I am now the elder, that I must now rely on my own authority in a different way. I can’t call mom up any more and
ask her what she thinks. I find myself, when in challenging situations, asking, “What would an elder do?” This
is becoming a very important question for me. What would an elder do?
I am sure that if I wrote this in 6 months, I would have very different insights that the cushion
of time would provide. I realize this must feel a little ragged, for I am not exactly off the island quite yet, but I guess
that is ok.
Thomas Lynch wrote about the death of his father is an essay included in the book, The Ultimate
Journey:
“As I watch my generation labor to give their teenagers and young adults some ‘family
values’ between courses of pizza and Big Macs, I think that maybe my father had it right. He understood that the meaning
of life is connected, inexplicably, to the meaning of death; that mourning is a romance in reverse, and if you love, you grieve,
and there are no exceptions. And if death is regarded as an embarrassment or an inconvenience, if the dead are regarded as
a nuisance from whom we seek a hurried riddance, then life and the living are in for similar treatment.”
So on this Memorial Day weekend, let us all pause and remember those friends, sons and daughters,
parents, and ancestors who have moved on before us, and hold them close in our hearts.
Plant a tree in their honor, or spread some wildflower seeds in celebration of their lives and
your continued appreciation of them. Let us all remember the important place death has in our lives, and draw on our courage
to face it.
I want to end these reflections with a quote from my favorite poet, Mary Oliver, and which we included
in the program for Mom’s service:
“To live in this world you must be able to do three things: to love what is mortal to
hold it against your bones knowing your own life depends on it, and when the time comes to let it go, to let it go.”
Mary Oliver
To use Kurt Moeller’s words when instructing pilots to fly: “Strap in, follow the needle,
and do not be afraid.”
|